37 Sherman Ave.
Take a tour
Step Inside
Property Highlights
A true masterpiece of design and craftsmanship on the east hill of Closter.This stunning property boasts over 8000 sqft with 6 spacious bedrooms and 7.5 bathrooms.The exterior a perfect blend of Hardie shingle & stone, metal & shingle roofing adds a touch of sophistication. Wide plank white oak flooring flows seamlessly throughout the home. The custom imported Italian kitchen is a chef's dream featuring high-end appliances & finishes. A beautifully designed wine cellar awaits, ready to house your finest collections. Entertain with ease in the expansive living areas ,which include a gym for your fitness needs & a bar for hosting guests. 3-car garage provides ample space for vehicles and storage. Every detail in this home is meticulously curated to offer unparalleled luxury and comfort. Owner has RE license and is listing agent.
Take a tour
Experience the Space
See your potential home from every angle. Take a closer look at the design, layout, and features that make this property special.
Discover the Layout
Floor Plans
Click a photo below to view full size
Gallery
37 Sherman Avenue: Closter’s Third-Highest NJMLS Sale of 2025
37 Sherman Avenue in Closter, New Jersey sold for $3,200,000, representing Closter’s third-highest residential sale recorded on the New Jersey Multiple Listing Service for 2025. Located on Closter’s East Hill, the property reflects the continued demand for newer luxury construction, substantial interior scale, high-end finishes, and well-positioned residential settings in Bergen County.
Property Significance
37 Sherman Avenue was presented as a luxury East Hill residence with over 8,000 square feet, 6 bedrooms, 7 full bathrooms, and 1 half bathroom. The home combined a large floor plan with custom design details, elevated finishes, and functional space across multiple levels.
The property featured wide-plank white oak flooring, a custom imported Italian kitchen, high-end appliances and finishes, a wine cellar, and a refined exterior combining Hardie shingle, stone, metal roofing, and shingle roofing. These details helped position the home among Closter’s most significant sales of 2025.
This sale is also meaningful within New Jersey Proper’s broader Closter results. After selling Closter’s #1 and #2 NJMLS residential sales for 2024, New Jersey Proper also represented major Closter sales in 2025, including 67 Hickory Lane and 37 Sherman Avenue.
Sale and Property Details
- Address 37 Sherman Avenue, Closter, NJ 07624
- Sale Price $3,200,000
- Market Distinction Closter’s third-highest NJMLS residential sale of 2025
- Bedrooms 6 bedrooms
- Bathrooms 7 full bathrooms and 1 half bathroom
- Interior Approximately 8,000 square feet
- Location East Hill, Closter, New Jersey
- Status Sold by New Jersey Proper
A Significant Closter Luxury Sale
The sale of 37 Sherman Avenue provides another important reference point for the upper end of Closter’s 2025 luxury market. As the borough’s third-highest NJMLS sale of the year, it reinforces buyer demand for larger luxury homes with newer construction, substantial interior square footage, and strong East Hill positioning.
Why was 37 Sherman Avenue a notable Closter sale?
37 Sherman Avenue sold for $3,200,000 and represented Closter’s third-highest residential sale recorded on the New Jersey Multiple Listing Service for 2025.
What are the main property details?
The home included 6 bedrooms, 7 full bathrooms, 1 half bathroom, and approximately 8,000 square feet in Closter, New Jersey.
What features helped define the property?
The property featured an East Hill location, over 8,000 square feet, wide-plank white oak flooring, a custom imported Italian kitchen, high-end appliances, a wine cellar, and an exterior combining Hardie shingle, stone, metal roofing, and shingle roofing.
What does this sale indicate about the Closter luxury market?
This sale reflects demand for larger luxury homes in Closter with substantial interior space, newer construction, upgraded finishes, and strong residential positioning.
Why does this matter for Closter luxury sellers?
The sale provides a useful 2025 benchmark for pricing, presentation, and buyer demand at the upper end of the Closter residential market.
Welcome to
The Charming Closter
Closter is one of Bergen County’s most desirable suburban communities, known for its charming neighborhoods, top-rated schools, and thriving downtown. Offering a perfect balance of suburban tranquility and modern convenience, Closter features luxury homes, new construction estates, and beautifully maintained properties surrounded by parks and nature. Residents enjoy upscale shopping and dining at Closter Plaza, excellent recreation, and easy access to Manhattan. With its strong community spirit and elegant lifestyle, Closter real estate continues to attract buyers seeking sophistication, comfort, and value in Northern New Jersey.
Contact Us
Request Information
Reach out if you have any questions and we’ll get back to you quickly.
Explore
Our Listings
Confirm your time
Fill in your details and we will contact you to confirm a time.
Contact Form
Welcome to our open house!
We encourage you to take a few seconds to fill out your information so we can send you exclusive updates for this listing!